Showing posts with label gamefication. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gamefication. Show all posts

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Gamefication in Schools

If you don't believe that video games are good educational tools, look up Ananth Pai.  I spent a few hours today watching TED videos on gamefication.  One gamefication expert mentioned this guy named Ananth Pai.  Mr. Pai is from India.  He is a teacher in the U.S. and mostly teaches 3rd grade.  His teaching record, based on tests scores of students, was just as crummy as most other U.S. teachers, until one day his 6th grade daughter suggested that his students might respond better if they were able to use Nintendo DS handheld consoles in the classroom for learning.  Initially, he thought her suggestion was absurd, and even said that he would never allow that.  Soon after though, he spent some time hanging out at BestBuy, asking children if they would like it if their classes used those game consoles for learning.  They all said that they would like that a lot.  So, Mr. Pai bought enough Nintendo DS consoles for his entire class (out of his own pockets, because the administration thought the idea was absurd).  Eventually, he added desktop computers, and even XBox Kinect.  His third grade class, which had started with math and reading skills below what is typically expected for a third grader, ended that school year with math and reading skills typically expected of students halfway through forth grade (they learned more than a grade and a half of material in one grade).  His students' test scores improved by 2 to 5 times what was typical for the school.  In addition, when those students moved on, they maintained their lead, even though the classes for later grades were not gamefied in any way.

This is one case of evidence that games are great learning tools.  As I have mentioned before, Khan Academy has shown that children will even respond well to game-like reward systems, with no other game-like elements.  Mr Pai's experience has caught the attention of several large corporations that regularly donate money to education, as well as education system officials for several states.  Unfortunately, this buzz happened in 2011, and we still don't have a large scale gamefication of schools in the U.S.  Why not?  We have all sorts of evidence that this works, and the U.S. education system is becoming one of the worst in the world.  Our government keeps trying to think of new ways to improve the education system, and in the process has managed to hobble it more successfully than it has ever been in the history of our country.  Why do we keep trying new things, hoping they will work, when the answer is staring us in the face?

Most Americans that do believe video games can be useful learning tools think that educational games have to be designed to be educational to be effective.  Up until today I believed that, to some degree.  Games like World of WarCraft have great benefits for general education and brain development, but they just don't teach specific subjects very consistently.  Some Wow players might get good at math from managing their imaginary in-game money.  Others might get better reading skills from reading all of the storyline text presented when accepting quests, or from communicating with other players.  Many players just ignore the difficult elements though.  The game is designed so that this does not make it much more difficult, because otherwise it would not retain players very well.  Most commercial games are designed so that players only have to learn what they want to learn from the game.  Besides that, many of the mental benefits of these games are not easily quantifiable and while they are useful real life skills, they are just not considered important enough to dedicate school time to learning (spatial memory and mapping skills, for instance).  It would be reasonable to assume, knowing only this, that games are good for general mental exercise and improvement, but not for learning specific subjects.  Today I learned that this is totally wrong.

Mr Pai bought store shelf commercial games for his Nintendo DS consoles.  He chose ones with obvious educational value, but not the kind of games that are specifically designed to teach 3rd graders math and reading.  One of the games was a collection of simple brain games.  These are intended to be mentally stimulating, but they were not designed to teach 3rd grade math.  They were designed to be entertaining.  One of these games casts the player in the role of a cashier.  The player rings up items, then takes payment for them.  The player must then count out the change for the payment.  Players get points when they count out the correct change.  Students in Mr. Pai's class would play this game and compete to see who could get the highest score.  This is one of the many games they used to improve their math skills.

The reason that these games are so successful at teaching is that they are engaging.  A typical classroom lecture is boring, especially to 3rd graders.  With usually only one hour per day and a class of 30 students, a teacher can only devote 2 minutes of personal time per student, assuming that no lecture is given.  A 30 minute lecture leaves only 1 minute per student.  This is not enough time for meaningful one on one time with all of the students that need it.  Engaging games encourage the students to learn on their own.  This leaves more time for the teacher to spend with students that really need help.  Mr. Pai also found that this eliminates the need for homework, giving the students more free time outside of class (though, nearly every study on the subject has found that more than 15 minutes per day of homework has no discernible benefits anyhow).  Some students would even play some of the online games they used in class at home after school, for entertainment.

In summary, there is plenty of evidence that gamefication is superior to everything else that we have tried for improving our education system.  The most effective learning games are not necessarily those designed specifically for learning.  Games that are engaging help keep the interest of students.  What we really need to do is find or make a bunch of games that are engaging and also happen to be educational, then use these game in our schools to teach our children.  Based on the results of people like Ananth Pai, and Salman Khan of Khan Academy, our educational system could easily and quickly become one of the best in the world, instead of one of the worst, if we would embrace gamefication, instead of treating it like an absurd joke.

Lord Rybec

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Video Game Stigma

In a speech, on August 8th, 1983, Ronald Regan said, "I recently learned something quite interesting about video games. Many young people have developed incredible hand, eye, and brain coordination in playing these games. The air force believes these kids will be our outstanding pilots should they fly our jets."  Typically when a U.S. President says something, the people listen.  In this case, however, they did not.  Most Americans, even those who play them regularly, still see video games as valueless time wasters that are nothing more than meaningless entertainment.  The hand eye coordination benefits of playing video games are the butt of many jokes.  What researchers did not know when Regan made this statement, and what a vast majority of Americans still do not know, is that video games have far more benefits than just coordination.

Five or six years ago, I read an article in either Scientific American or Discover magazine.  I cannot find a reference for the article because neither of those magazines' websites have decent search capability, and there are so many articles on the subject that even Google is no help.  The author of this article was working on a research project on sensory benefits of certain sensory disabilities.  It has been known for some time that people who are blind or deaf tend to have heightened ability in the other senses.  This researcher wanted to find exactly how far these sensory benefits went, so he made some computer programs to test things like reflexes and coordination.  He found that people with sensory disabilities performed significantly better on all of his tests than people without any sensory disabilities.  Then one day, he decided to try the tests himself.  He scored off the charts.  His scores beat both the normal test subjects and the disabled ones, by a wide margin.  After testing the other researchers he worked with, along with some other people, he found that the link was computer games.  People who regularly played computer games consistently scored much higher than even people with sensory disabilities.  This researcher ended up changing his research to find the effects of video games on the human brain.  In his article, he compares playing video games to working out for the brain.  Further research found that video games can improve social skills, mathematical skills, quick decision making skills, risk assessment skills, spatial memory skills, reflexes, physical and mental coordination, as well as any number of different types of problem solving skills, and many other skills.

Other recent research has found even more beneficial uses of games in general.  A Deseret News article I recently read advocated the use of games for improving family life.  The article cited research showing that playing games (including board and cards games, as well as video games) occupies the logical centers of our brains, which makes us less hesitant about discussing difficult subjects.  In family settings, this can help keep discussions on controversial topics more civil and more likely to occur in the first place.

Jane McGonigal, a gaming advocate, has given several TED talks on how video games can improve society.  Her focus is on family life improvement and building problem solving skills that will be useful for solving some of the world's most difficult problems.  She recommends playing no less than 20 hours of games a week.  She suggests that MMORPGs are especially good, because of the cooperative social interaction, but says that multiplayer games in person are even better.  Ideally, she says that cooperative in-person games are the best, because they build teamwork skills and strengthen relationships.  In one TED talk, she also explains and shows how turning a difficult task into a game can make it much easier, or at least less tedious and more engaging.

I also have some personal experience with the benefits of video games.  Many years ago, I attended a youth group, where we played volleyball weekly.  I noticed that most people who joined our games were not very coordinated when they started and often took many months to improve their skill.  There were some people, however, that were very coordinated and could play well, without any prior experience.  There were a few differences between those who could play well right off and those who could not.  People with prior experience in other sports tended to be fairly good right off.  There were some people though, that were good right off, but that had no real athletic experience.  Most of these people were actually not very physically fit either.  This was because they spent a lot of time playing video games.  Somehow, they could play as well as some people with prior vollyball experience, even though they were unathletic, with no real experience in any sport.  The benefits to coordination, reflexes, and quick decision making from playing video games were very clear.

A lot of research showing the beneficial effects of games is not limited to video games.  Most games can have some beneficial effect, and different games have different beneficial effects.  For instance, Tetris is great for basic problem solving, reflexes, coordination, and fast decision making, while Dungeons and Dragons is great for cooperative social skills, relationship building, advanced problem solving, and even basic mathematical skills.  Video games tend to focus more on fast decision making, reflexes, coordination, while non-video games focus more on advanced problem solving, risk assessment, and social skills.  Obviously some games cross boundaries, but there are some skills that do not cross boundaries well.  In short, not all of the benefits of video games can be gained from non-video games, and not all of the benefits of non-video games can be gained from video games.  For the full benefits, a variety of games and game types are important.

We need to get over this social stigma of video games.  Admittedly, video games can be addictive, and like working out, if you do not use what you gain from it, it is worthless.  I think, however, that eliminating the social stigma around video games would solve part of this problem.  Many gamers feel isolated by this social stigma, so they spend most of their time playing video games, because at least on the games, they have friends who do not judge their hobby.  Ironically, these gamers tend to be smarter than the people who judge them, and recent research has shown that many of them even have better social skills, because they work with other people solving in-game problems regularly (many MMORPGs are more social than workplaces or even bars).  If our society did not push these gamers into isolation, they would probably spend less time playing games and more time working with other people to solve real world problems, and they would be extremely good at it, because of the problem solving skills gained playing games.  Also, if society stopped pushing gamers into isolation, maybe more people would play games, and the average intelligence of our society would improve.  If this happened, maybe all of these extremely difficult problems we are facing would not be so difficult anymore.

One thing we need to consider is what is really important in our society?  Many schools and colleges place emphasis on certain types of games.  These are sports, an athletic kind of game that does have some benefits in common with other types of games.  The primary benefit of sports are all physical though.  Sports improve our strength and endurance.  They can also improve coordination to some degree, but they do not improve our mental function as much as games that challenge the mind (there is strong evidence that physical exercise does improve cognitive function, but only on a general level).  This seems to indicate that our society values physical fitness more than mental fitness.  Ironically, much of our media supports this theory.  Also, ironically, the most important jobs are not ones where anyone cares about physical fitness.  Some of the best paying and highest demand jobs are engineering jobs, where mental fitness is the only qualifying factor.  Engineers are not muscular, skinny people with great bodies.  They are extremely smart people with well developed minds.  So, why are we not having more "sports" in schools and colleges that emphasize mental fitness?  Some colleges, including MIT, have StarCraft 2 teams, but most traditional colleges have at least football, basketball, and volleyball teams, and many also include baseball and softball, but nothing to challenge the mind.  These skills will be great for the fraction of a percent of students who become professional athletes, but for the rest of us the only benefit is better physical fitness, which could easily be achieved by walking or running to our classes instead of driving.

I would like to see more video games in schools.  I don't mind if they are educational games, since this is really the goal, but they should also be engaging games, otherwise students will not want to play them and will get far less benefits from them.  Also, while StarCraft 2 is a great competitive game and teaches a lot of useful skills, we need some cooperative games as well.  Jane McGonigal recommends 20 hours of games per week.  I do not think this should all occur in school (otherwise half of school time would be gaming), but even 2 or 3 hours a week would have beneficial effects.  In elementary school students typically get an hour of recess per day (usually 30 minutes at a time), and an hour of lunch that includes some recess time after eating.  This is more than enough physical activity to maintain good fitness (not to mention the PE classes that involve even more physical activity).  What if, two days a week, that hour of recess was spent playing games instead?  The students would still have the recess time during lunch for physical activity.  The game time could begin and end with restroom breaks, so the students are not sitting still for too long at a time.  If the games could be played in short intervals, they could be played during the normal 30 minute recess times, otherwise the school could schedule time differently for those days, to make the time 1 continuous hour.  Highschools and colleges could offer game class time or extracurricular game time much like they currently offer sports.  Note that I am not saying they should eliminate sports entirely, but I think that if sports are considered a valuable asset to students, games should be considered at least as valuable, since they offer more practical benefits than physical sports.

Also, games are usually cheaper than physical sports.  For a given sport, schools or students often end up paying hundreds of dollars per student for equipment.  Most schools already have a computer lab, and multiple students can use a computer if they are scheduled at different times (much like the same field can be used for multiple sports, as long as it is scheduled well), so computer costs are already covered.  The best games for this sort of thing do not cost more than $60 per copy, and most cost substantially less, so even if each student needs their own copy, the per student cost for student specific equipment is not more than $60 per sport (and, for account based games like StarCraft 2, many students will already have their own account).  Also, this is typically a one time cost, while physical sports often require new equipment regularly, as the old equipment wears out.  New computers will only be needed if new game courses are added that require better computers, or if there are too many students and there are not enough computers to go around.  Our society and our schools embrace extracurricular games that build skills that are not very relevant to our modern civilization, when they could be embracing games that build useful and relevant skills for much cheaper.

Focusing of physical sports and physical fitness is great if we are trying to raise a generation of construction workers, but what we really need are engineers and problem solvers.  Games can help give us these.  Games are to mental fitness as working out is to physical fitness.  Since our current civilization needs mentally fit people much more than physically fit people, our culture needs to embrace gaming as a means of improving and progressing.  If we can eliminate this video game stigma that our society has harbored for far too long, I believe that we can progress much faster and solve many of our most difficult problems much more easily.

Lord Rybec

Monday, August 22, 2011

Gamefication

Gamefication is the process of turning something that is generally considered a tedious or difficult task into a game, at least in the minds of the people participating in the activity. Examples suggested or tried in literature and research I have read on the subject include using a leader board to keep track of water usage during rationing (specifically, the lower the per person water usage in a home, the higher that home scores), or putting video games in urinals that encourage users to aim better (ok, this is mildly distasteful, but it has actually been done with great success). The greatest benefit of gamefication is that it gives people incentives to perform better, even if that incentive is only bragging rights, and the research that has been done with gamefication has been extremely successful.

I would like to see gamefication added to education. In some small areas this has already been done, for instance spelling bees, academic decathlons, and the college I attend even does integration bees. These are generally limited to students that seem to have natural talent in these areas and are thus seen as "nerd" clubs. Most students are either not allowed to enter because they are not very skilled, or choose not to enter because they believe that they do not posses the skill (or because they fear the teasing that often comes with natural talent). What I want to see is all of education gamefied.

Wholesale gamefication of education may seem like a very difficult task. I do not believe that it is. Actually, it has already been done, for a limited range of subjects. I have previously mentioned the badge system used by Khan Academy. When a student performs at a satisfactory level in the exercises for a particular milestone, the student receives an electronic "badge" for that milestone. Again, as I have mentioned, Khan Academy notes that some fifth graders have begun to competitively learn on the website, in an effort to collect more badges. Some of these students have completed subjects equivalent to entire college level courses in order to increase their collection of badges. Khan Academy has already begun gamefying education. As the site continues to grow, we will have more and more subjects that are gamefied. As educational research, Khan Academy's results with its system are showing that gamefying education has great potential in encouraging students to educate themselves. I doubt wholesale gamefication of our education system would have less dramatic results.

Given the success of Khan Academy's gamefied education system, and the success of games in general, I believe that gamefying education could, by itself, dramatically improve the average education of US citizens. Admittedly, our education system does need other things as well, but the experience from Khan Academy shows that at least some students will educate themselves if they have even mild incentives. Our current system works entirely by forcing education down the throats of the students. Admittedly, some students adapt more quickly than others, but when the system is made into a game, many students will become proactive about their own education. It is true that they may be doing it for credit and bragging rights more than for the value of the education, but these students will remember what they learn far better than those who only work hard enough to barely get by and then forget everything at the end of the semester.

Gamefication of our education system, I believe, is an essential step in becoming the best education system on the face of the planet. I believe that this could even help us beat the education of oriental countries, if done promptly and correctly.

Lord Rybec

Sunday, August 21, 2011

Milestone Based Education

Our current education system has divided subjects into sections that are intended to be taught by semester. The division is entirely arbitrary. No one went to any effort to determine how much information is reasonable to learn over a given amount of time, they just decided where to cut based on personal preferences and opinions. The result is that some classes are excessively difficult in the time given and some are excessively easy.

Because classes are divided into semesters, the subject matter must be taught at a set rate, otherwise the class might get behind and will not have learned all the subject matter by the time they are expected to. This system expects all the students to learn at the same rate. It also expects each student to learn each sub-section of the subject at the same rate as all the other students. This causes two problems. The first is that some students learn faster than others and this system holds them back. This can make a student become tired of a subject that they are extremely good at, making them dislike that subject. The result is that a student that could be a great asset to industry and technological advancement ends up in some job that does little for society, because they don't like the things they are good at (or worse, they don't even know they are good at it in the first place). Second, and much more common, a student may struggle with some principle partway through the semester. Unfortunately, the teacher and the rest of the class will go on without that student. This student learns the rest of the subject perfectly fine, but that one thing they missed can result in a poor grade or even failing the class entirely. One extra day covering that missed principle might have prevented the problem, but with 20 or more other students in the class, the teacher cannot afford the time to give an extra day to every student that needs it.

The problem here is that in most classes, many of the students have difficulty with various principles of the subject. Some manage to figure it out on their own, but others do not. Many students come out of their classes with Bs, Cs, and Ds, or even Fs, because they missed something simple early on, that made the entire rest of the class impossible. Many of these students have to retake the classes, wasting an entire semester because they missed something simple that could have been resolved in only one or two days. In high school, this results in late graduation. In college, it results in additional costs to the student as well as potential risk of loosing scholarships and grants. The overall cost of these problems is enormous, to individual students as well as to the taxpayers. This also destroys the many students' confidence in their abilities, making them hate subjects that they might be good at and causing more difficulty the further they get in school.

This can be solved with a milestone based learning system. This sort of system does not have a formal semester based class structure. Students are allowed to learn at their own pace, so long as their rate of progress does not become too low. Subjects are divided into small milestones that should generally take less than a week to complete (but more complex ones may take more). Once the student provides sufficient evidence of understanding of the subject material of the milestone, is it passed off and they can continue to the next. Some students may find that they can pass off what would have been an entire semester class in only a week or two. Others (or the same student in a different subject) may take more than a semester for a particular subject. Students that are doing well in a subject may need little or no attention from a teacher, while slower students may need extra attention. This allows teachers to teach where needed and stay out of the way where they are not needed. This allows students that are good in a subject to complete that subject extremely quickly so they can spend more time on subjects where they need it.

Khan Academy is doing research using a milestone based system, with a lot of success. BYU Idaho is also experimenting with a milestone based system. So far evidence has shown that most students have a number of subjects that they will do enough faster than a semester based system requires that they can learn more in less time than a semester based system allows, using a milestone based system instead. In short, most students perform better and learn faster in a milestone based system than in a semester based system.

Another major benefit of a milestone based system is that it can be gamefied very easily. This helps to encourage students to work at as fast a pace as they can handle. Khan Academy has gamefied its system by keeping track of milestones with "badges". Many students have started to learn competitively in an effort to accumulate as many badges as possible. Learning has become a game, and thus fun, for these students. Doing something like this with our entire education system could dramatically improve the education of high school graduates in the US, not because the education system has improved itself, but because the students will be treating learning as a competitive game, where they are rated by how much they have learned (ie, how many badges they have accumulated). Many students will come out of high school with a deep knowledge and understanding of subjects that many college students are currently struggling with. I will discuss gamefication of education in more depth later, but this is quite possibly one of the greatest benefits of a milestone based education system. Making education into a game will encourage the students to become proactive in their education, which is more valuable than any other single improvement we could make to the education system.

Lord Rybec